Ancient / Classical History

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Ancient / Classical History

Unfair to Julius Caesar!

Caesar Was a Leader with Stature

From Wilson Bertram, for About.com

If Caesar is to be compared with any American presidents, it should not be with the buffoons and poltroons, but with those of some stature who led, and not just presided, through changing and troubled circumstances. The three who come to mind are Roosevelt, Lincoln and Washington. The first may be comparable for political deviousness, and silver tongued oratory, as well as for long term ambition - and in the suspicion he aroused about his 'kingly' presumptions. The hen pecked corporate lawyer and compromise presidential candidate who presided tragically over a bitter civil war, may have had little but his steely determination in common with Caesar. None of them had the range and depth of Caesar, but probably Washington comes closest. A dourer character, but the Father of his country; and assuredly the Romans would have respected his gravitas and auctoritas. A competent and finally successful general and politician, the wags of his time expressed sly surprise that Washington found the time and energy to fight a war as well as pay his compliments to all the ladies who demanded his attention.

Of course, there is still a big difference between the situations of Caesar and his fellows, and that of the Americans; namely the degree of decadence of their institutions and constitutions. The Americans had, and still have, more public respect for their institutions. Incumbents may be incompetent and unworthy, the public light minded and indifferent, but there is still confidence in the legitimacy and effectiveness of the institutions. Political rivals do not have to take desperate measures to preserve their own lives by killing their opponents. In Caesar's world the constitutionalists who wanted to restore such good old ways wrung their hands ineffectually, as powerful individuals subordinated the institutions of the state to their own interests and egos, reconstituting their world around themselves, and the public sought their own safety by acclaiming them.

To be one of the rulers in such a world, and finally the supreme ruler, is a very different thing from being even the highest servant or hereditary monarch of a constitutional state. It is to be a predator, superior to ordinary men, but required to develop ones abilities and suspicions to the full, to always be on the alert against attack by someone stronger or more cunning. This must require and develop self confidence abilities and zest for life beyond the usual run,to greatness of some sort, to the divinity or beastiality predicted by Aristotle for those who are not bound by the usual rules of the polis, but it is likely to lead to one end; which is that of the criminal priest king of the grove of Nemi, "the one who slew the slayer, who shall himself be slain."

Wilson Bertram was born in Ireland, educated in England and lives in South Africa.

Caesar Study Guide

N.S. Gill
Guide since 1997

N.S. Gill
Ancient History Guide

Explore Ancient / Classical History

About.com Special Features

Ancient / Classical History

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Ancient / Classical History
  4. People and Places
  5. People
  6. Julius Caesar
  7. Julius Caesar Assassination
  8. Caesar Was a Leader with Stature

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.