1. Education

Discuss in my forum

Book Review

About.com Rating 5 Star Rating
Be the first to write a review

By , About.com Guide

The Bottom Line

Imperium, a suspenseful novel about Cicero, polarizes: Some are bored, others love it. If you enjoyed Harris' novel Pompeii, try Imperium. Instead of detouring to more popular Roman hotshots -- like Caesar and Pompey -- Harris sticks to his topic, the statesman and bane of many Latin students, the very wordy Cicero, told from the fly-on-the-wall perspective of his slave and scribe, Tiro, who may have invented shorthand out of need.
<!--#echo encoding="none" var="lcp" -->

Pros

  • Turns Cicero into a complex human
  • Clearly renders events near the end of the Roman Republic
  • Is not the story of Caesar
  • Extremely easy to read

Cons

  • Some anachronisms
  • One noticeable less than smooth transition - hardly a serious fault
  • Some important characters burst on the scene and then disappear

Description

  • Tiro narrates the story from the vantage point of the end of a very long life.
  • Imperium describes Cicero from the time Tiro entered his service until he won a consulship.
  • The first half goes through the trial of Verres.
  • Terentia and Cicero have class-based conflicts, but love each other deeply, in Harris' version.
  • Cicero has trouble winning over the aristocracy, but learns to make compromises.
  • Only reluctantly, and not well explained, Cicero joins forces with Pompey.
  • Cicero had his personality quirks that made and still make some like him and others cringe.
  • Imperium evidently has the same effect on people, which suggests Harris got it right.
  • If you dislike Cicero, Robert Harris may redeem him for you.
  • Loose ends should be covered in the sequels.

Guide Review - Book Review

If you're reading historical fiction, you probably want to be entertained by a good story, written by a talented writer who doesn't make you sit up to verify glaring anachronisms or notice wobbly intrusions of the writer on every page. Imperium, by Robert Harris, is deliciously palatable biographical fiction, especially for those who have forgotten Cicero. However, if you want to wallow in anachronisms, fellow historical fiction writer Ross Leckie takes Harris to task (adrianmurdoch.typepad.com/bread_and_circuses/2006/09/imperium.html).

Some question why Harris ends when Cicero won the bid for consul. Cicero's election to consul is just about the pinnacle of his career. If you like Cicero, that's where you want it to end. If you find him a prig who got what was coming, Harris will produce the sequels.

Although Harris may warrant comparison with Steven Saylor, as a smooth historical fiction writer covering the same era, Saylor writes mysteries. However exciting Cicero's rise to power may be, the fictional biography is in Colleen McCullough's genre, not mystery.

Among legitimate biographies of Cicero, Everitt's makes Cicero little more than a background character for Julius Caesar, for which reason it's fitting that Caesar is little more than a cloak floating past in the background of Imperium.

<!--#echo encoding="none" var="lcp" -->
Disclosure: A review copy was provided by the publisher. For more information, please see our Ethics Policy.

©2013 About.com. All rights reserved.