Ancient / Classical History

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Ancient / Classical History

Fall of Rome - Decline of the Roman Empire

Reasons for the decline of the Roman Empire.

By N.S. Gill, About.com

Hadrian's Wall

Hadrian's Wall

NSGill
It's not entirely arbitrary that Medieval/Renaissance History at About.com begins and Ancient/Classical History ends in A.D. 476. Edward Gibbon's 476 date for the Fall of Rome is conventionally acceptable because that's when the Germanic Odoacer deposed the last Roman emperor to rule the Western Empire. However, the people who lived through the takeover would probably be surprised by the importance we place on this event. And there are other, reasonably momentous dates for the Fall of the Roman Empire.

Some say Rome fell when it was split into an eastern and a western empire ruled by separate emperors. The eastern half became the Byzantine Empire, with its capital at Constantinople (modern Istanbul). The western half remained centered in Italy. Many say the Fall was an ongoing process lasting more than a century. Since Rome still exists, it could even be argued it never fell. Some prefer to say that Rome adapted rather than fell. [For some more details, see End of Rome.] A related question, one subject to even more discussion is:
Why did Rome Fall?

There are adherents to single factors, but more people think Rome fell because of a combination of such factors as Christianity, decadence, lead, monetary trouble, and military problems. Even the rise of Islam is proposed as the reason for Rome's fall, by some who think the Fall of Rome happened at Constantinople in the 15th Century.

Causes of the Fall of Rome

Here are some of the explanations for the Fall of Rome:

Early Historian of the Fall of Rome

Those who want to look back at the first major historian to deal with the decline and fall of Rome should read about the fifth century historian Zosimus.
See Zosimus - The First Major Historian of the Fall of the Roman Empire.

Modern Books on the Fall of Rome

There are 3 books from 2005 devoted to the topic:
  • In 2007, an English translation of Alessandro Barbero's 2005 The Day of the Barbarians was published. Barbero blames the 4th century Battle of Adrianople and its aftermath for the fall of the Western Empire. After the battle, which was in the Eastern Empire, the successors of the loser, the Emperor Valens, managed to push the barbarians westward where they continued to look unsuccessfully for land and acceptance until they sacked Rome.

  • The Fall of Rome: And the End of Civilization, by Bryan Ward-Perkins, who believes that Rome fell and rejects the idea that Rome ended without catastrophe or decay. Ward-Perkins refers anecdotally to an odd German book, Der Fall Roms. Die Auflosung des Romischen Reiches im Urteil der Nachwelt, by Alexander Demandt, which contains "a compendium of verdicts on the fall of Rome." 400 of such verdicts occurred between 1800 and 1965. If you're interested in bizarre reasons, check out the list.

  • The Fall of the Roman Empire: A New History of Rome and the Barbarians, by Peter Heather
    Heather's thesis is that the various assaults on Rome had ripple effects. Rome lost territory and revenue, was spread too thin militarily, and the barbarians on the border kept growing stronger. One attack was not enough, but the cumulative effect caused the fall of the western empire.
    Review

Articles on the End of the Roman Empire

Rome and Roman Empire Maps

Decay, Christianity, Vandals, and Religious Controversy as Reasons for the Fall of Rome

Roman Empire Map A.D. 395

Users Respond: Do you think Rome fell? If so, when and why?

Natural death

I think that the "fall" of the Roman empire wasn't a single event but rather the culmination of a myriad of events and circumstances. Rome was slowly overwhelmed, largely because of things happening outside the empire, forces out of its control. Rome had existed a long time. Nothing lasts for ever - and, as was pointed out, the "final" end was probably nowhere near as final or even obvious to the people who lived through it. This fall of the (western) Roman empire was basically a natural event that wasn't even a single, easily defined event as such. I tend to agree, to some extent, that Rome never really "fell". It is true that it is no longer an empire, but it has continued to influence almost every aspect of our lives, of western culture, to this day. I don't think you can say Rome "died" or fell in whatever year you want to assign to that. Rome is still here, still with us, and even IN us.
—Guest Neil

Taxation

Many factors contributed to the fall of Rome, but the main idea is that Rome was overtaxed while the denarii (their form of money) was devalued over 200%. The Roman lifestyle became purely militaristic and caused the army to be less effected. The poor increased and government help (because welfare was invented in Rome) caused an even greater burden on the economy. Over 50 years Rome had 20 emperors each averaging 2 1/2 years. All of them met violent deaths. The military elected and assassinated for their own good. -- port charlotte high
—Guest in honors class'

Why the Empire fell

It fell due to the many problems that they faced, such as road systems, emperor problems, etc. Poor people got poorer, and the rich also became poor. Another reason is that the government ran out of money, which affected the whole empire.
—Guest Purple

It Was Caesar

Rome fell when Julius Caesar was killed and removed from power. It began the fall of the empire because after Caesar was killed, other people tried to take control, but were not strong enough to handle the power.
—Guest mike

Combination of Causes

Rome fell because it simply got too large to rule over, and because of the constant barbaric invasions making Rome always on the defense, and because they needed a strong defensive army taxes had to be raised, making the economy horrible. Seemingly smaller things also triggered it, lead poisoning, plagues, too much reliance on slaves and not enough on inventions and progression (slaves die out and become scarce), over-use of soil in agriculture making it useless, and finally Christianity (as Christianity made people more about being an individually moral person and not think of greater society, especially during times of war.)
—Guest alda

Share Your Opinions

Do you think Rome fell? If so, when and why?

All fields required

50-character minimum

1000-character limit

Log in to Your Account

Forgot your password?

N.S. Gill
Guide since 1997

N.S. Gill
Ancient History Guide

Explore Ancient / Classical History

More from About.com

Ancient / Classical History

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Ancient / Classical History

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.